以下純粹是自己的看法,可能有失偏頗83Please respect copyright.PENANAK8DpvDp6gz
而且可能有點長,注意!!!83Please respect copyright.PENANAjOoLsUfBrU
我是中學才入的HP坑,直到現在我其實還是對他的分類存疑83Please respect copyright.PENANA1gcHCoyRBv
(拜託,誰家的兒童讀物是打打殺殺啦!)83Please respect copyright.PENANA9QFm3yr91C
以下分一下說的部分
一、世界觀
二、對一部分角色的看法
三、總看法
83Please respect copyright.PENANAs944jTKYhZ
一、世界觀83Please respect copyright.PENANAjg4yZm8Jub
就世界觀來說83Please respect copyright.PENANAFY9PxbIflQ
作者應該只是很單純想寫英國的魔法故事83Please respect copyright.PENANAT9yVNFZ2h4
對於布斯巴頓和德姆斯特朗學校的形容只有很片面的法國學校跟德國學校,像是為了寫出三巫鬥法大賽才生出來的東西83Please respect copyright.PENANAwSOtX2Ahcd
沒有詳細的設定,就像是只為了劇情而生出了讓人感興趣的空殼83Please respect copyright.PENANADyUg8pJ8KZ就很基本的爽流腦袋半下線吧
就宏觀來說JK創造了龐大的世界但用了很小的地方給男主走劇情(對我來說
83Please respect copyright.PENANAPBlbSNylWl
二、角色83Please respect copyright.PENANAvdEkYwoCj9
1. Harry Potter83Please respect copyright.PENANAntpJYSKODJ
很小就肩負起要殺Voldemort 的責任83Please respect copyright.PENANACxlDy3e739
基本上他的每一個行為都是偏向被迫(第一集除外)83Please respect copyright.PENANAcjbk5VWnyg
魔法界差不多每個人都覺得他是被寵大的83Please respect copyright.PENANA3fKyn5qGeA
因此他的行為都被冠上自大83Please respect copyright.PENANADbnep7Ifpa
Snap針對他的時候我都超想扶額的83Please respect copyright.PENANAQOzKMrDhBs
很多人都覺得Snap太毒舌,太亂針對人83Please respect copyright.PENANAdsW6lwqRY4
但說實話從他每一次說的話都可以看出他對Harry 生活的誤解83Please respect copyright.PENANA6OEQo1MMDu
有的人覺得他就是標準的大男主角色83Please respect copyright.PENANAwjBCLOhjNZ
但就我自己的見解,如果少一點被算計83Please respect copyright.PENANAJGjPFNwqrB
Harry 就跟一個普通小朋友一樣,是不會走上和Voldemort 死鬥的路83Please respect copyright.PENANA7Vqzpxr3a0
83Please respect copyright.PENANALeY4e4hfid
2.Draco Malfoy83Please respect copyright.PENANAt6niSd8V4t
每個人都覺得他是反派的天真小朋友83Please respect copyright.PENANAm9Rmvekw0q
Draco真的是可以以一個小朋友來稱呼83Please respect copyright.PENANAviHus7j4pe
作為一個被寵大的孩子83Please respect copyright.PENANArOGihGxCJe
如果Harry 父母沒死,被寵大的他一定會跟Draco 有相同的性格83Please respect copyright.PENANAQOSAKC0QB0
他雖然處處針對Harry 83Please respect copyright.PENANAErPBUsgXGQ
但比起經常受欺負而成長的Harry,他的心思嫩得像個憨憨83Please respect copyright.PENANA95yRwkC3ME
除了只用言語挑事跟告爸爸基本上沒有大殺傷力83Please respect copyright.PENANAbPcZ9uRorm
在Half-Blood Prince中他雖然加入了食死徒83Please respect copyright.PENANATBVt8FMrhA
但如果從他的背景來看,他算是無可奈可83Please respect copyright.PENANAKN2y3iP9Rw
因為如果他不做Voldemort 要他做的,死的是父母不一定是他83Please respect copyright.PENANAJDzIHVKzjD
他背負的不只有家族的榮譽,還有父母的命83Please respect copyright.PENANABE0RtgePAc
83Please respect copyright.PENANA5zGxjA0How
3.Severus Snap83Please respect copyright.PENANAtjZzkd7byR
Deathly Hallow中從大反派一躍成國民老公的傳奇人物83Please respect copyright.PENANA6O1c19xRsh
看到他抱著Lily哭的時候就知道事情不簡單83Please respect copyright.PENANA4BG1NsUvRb
可惜他的情深就成了被操縱成為棋子的關鍵83Please respect copyright.PENANASaTQlV3ObH
他的毒舌以及故事中學生們對他不好的評價成了大家覺得他是反派的基礎83Please respect copyright.PENANAxvJXOUVtE7
盡管誤會過後都會出現反轉83Please respect copyright.PENANAFoIQyLy60E
但在一開始看到他把Albus殺死時83Please respect copyright.PENANARPM8CmLPVe
比起覺得他有苦衷我更偏向覺得狐狸終於露出尾巴83Please respect copyright.PENANA0uyCIT10Dg
他的深情以及強大都讓我很愛這個角色83Please respect copyright.PENANAbSaMwguXsF
但作為一個以師長之姿而死,我覺得其實他可以走得更遠83Please respect copyright.PENANAIyaIQnKGhn
83Please respect copyright.PENANAYIjnEo3lHR
4.Albus Dumbledore83Please respect copyright.PENANAvdkkGNZ44M
為了遠大的理想,他可以連自己也算計進去83Please respect copyright.PENANAlmO9MqWu6w
對我來說,他跟Grindelwald沒甚麼分別83Please respect copyright.PENANAB14RiKMjQF
有的人覺得作為一個老人我不應該對他有太大的責備83Please respect copyright.PENANATqIbJXAh0L
但疑問的種子從一開始就種下了83Please respect copyright.PENANAM1F2q3AovA
首先是隱身衣83Please respect copyright.PENANAcORKmZ6N7s
Albus 不會不知道隱身衣可以躲過一劫,但他卻沒有歸還給Potter 家83Please respect copyright.PENANAi4G6DOWfSK
是不是因為他知道,Neville沒辦法長成他希望的樣子所以才想操縱預言呢?83Please respect copyright.PENANAmpv0YUarcO
還是他真的只是單純研究,這我真的無從而知83Please respect copyright.PENANA98tODajq4y
其次,魔法石83Please respect copyright.PENANAkj6CbDlYRO
明明有那麼多天可以處理,他就偏挑接Harry那天才叫Hagrid去領東西83Please respect copyright.PENANAtAyLSdQIgD
而且一般新生也是由正規老師帶他們去對角巷83Please respect copyright.PENANA4NVUJXxZCk
就Harry 是由Hagrid 去83Please respect copyright.PENANAccoz1mgsLU
怎麼看就怎麼奇怪83Please respect copyright.PENANAHWiAkqwElQ
當然也有其他的論點就不一一說了83Please respect copyright.PENANARAv3OEfqbm
字數會太多83Please respect copyright.PENANA7XphzpFgiH
83Please respect copyright.PENANAiB93pZsZhX
5.Neville83Please respect copyright.PENANAgsY0FJfEGa
一直充當配角工具人的他,在Deathly Hallow才發現原來他也是預言之子之一啊……83Please respect copyright.PENANA1xwua92vrC
這……真的挺缺排面的83Please respect copyright.PENANAflivrMewdB
而且JK在書中對他的成長之路也沒有很多的說明,因此在大戰前我對他的印象也只有83Please respect copyright.PENANAg9Cde0aqsO
坩鍋殺手、寵物又不見了、惹禍專家、出現得都很莫名的工具人83Please respect copyright.PENANAWLGsbf1Y8e
83Please respect copyright.PENANAHtulL71so0
Hermione 和Ron 我就不多說了83Please respect copyright.PENANASsBzoEHVV2
他們的也很長83Please respect copyright.PENANA2ViVwkPONf
83Please respect copyright.PENANAAstULI1AJX
三、總看法83Please respect copyright.PENANAh2W86KBKJt
作為一個HP迷,我是挺迷這個故事,以致由這個IP所衍生出來的遊戲跟現實週邊我是一個都不會漏的83Please respect copyright.PENANAzCnrwvzRcD
JK創作了一個很好的故事83Please respect copyright.PENANA3oHU0j0Lq3
雖然我覺得它真的很應該放青少年讀物而不是兒童83Please respect copyright.PENANAtzYwvwU3gV
但她給全世界創做了一個魔法夢83Please respect copyright.PENANA9Cc5MTXLUb
而且直到今天夢還在繼續83Please respect copyright.PENANAFviT4IAfVJ
如果去細究,故事中夾帶了不少的私貨83Please respect copyright.PENANAWYwfIsRGDp
也許是給兒童看的關係?這些私貨又好像沒那麼重要了83Please respect copyright.PENANAkbwNHUkDeZ