x
No Plagiarism!uGzVszmNAUiwmmYRzHS3posted on PENANA 「殺人係咪一定係『錯』?會唔會以另一個角度睇係一件好事?」教授的聲音響徹了講堂。8964 copyright protection392PENANAoukuw9kp21 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAlHJTUoIMYb
8964 copyright protection392PENANAOZWvfrivv1 維尼
嗯……這個教授,有點東西。8964 copyright protection392PENANAMYmRtN6wqm 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAeBUfafxgOS
8964 copyright protection392PENANAAHAH0piUxH 維尼
「可以減少地球的生態壓力。」一名戴眼鏡少女冷冷的道,這個學生,也有點東西。8964 copyright protection392PENANA3S7NGVt78K 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAVNeUakNeco
8964 copyright protection392PENANA0szXMWh8fZ 維尼
「呢件事,要由唔同角度睇,以法律層面嚟講,殺人係錯嘅,所以殺人要受到法律制裁,而以殺人犯嘅角度嚟睇呢,佢可以從殺人獲得快樂或者利益,所以對殺人犯嚟講,佢係做緊件啱嘅事。」偉也接著回答。8964 copyright protection392PENANAt1EOAOmqzg 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAAnVhZ4IyZv
8964 copyright protection392PENANAlHS61wKQPZ 維尼
……殺人獲得快樂?有可能嗎?8964 copyright protection392PENANAgfpq09PlCJ 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAeCNGyTCbiW
8964 copyright protection392PENANAtKcsAL3wJ8 維尼
嗯……8964 copyright protection392PENANAWr84TdVB5S 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAoEAM9CghOV
8964 copyright protection392PENANArn01avqWqw 維尼
是有可能的,記得自己曾經於雪地中與三公里外的狙擊手對狙,成功於第四槍射殺了他,同時成功破了2.5公里最長射殺距離的世界紀錄。8964 copyright protection392PENANAUb577ADo04 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA1TlxY84FaC
8964 copyright protection392PENANAFvCOnkKtyi 維尼
同時我的確感受到無比的興奮與快樂。8964 copyright protection392PENANAhnS9e9mhwP 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAyXDxKH6Riz
8964 copyright protection392PENANAalqy6LEbaL 維尼
但這樣也不能推論「殺人犯會從殺戮這一行為中獲得快樂」。8964 copyright protection392PENANAIxQRcZAe6T 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA0dHZUpzM9k
8964 copyright protection392PENANAo8I832LOTb 維尼
令我快樂的也可能是「對狙的勝利」或「破世界紀錄」這兩個「殺戮」衍生出來的結果,而並非「殺戮」這個行為本身。8964 copyright protection392PENANAI34LIbPv3L 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAB8h9ngVF6B
8964 copyright protection392PENANAFTphgijonb 維尼
無可否認的是,以因果論來說的話,「殺人犯會從殺戮這一行為中獲得快樂」對我來說是成立的。8964 copyright protection392PENANAiunOIFBpMp 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA9x875TutAg
8964 copyright protection392PENANAZ2kbkSQSmS 維尼
我是在做錯的事?但我只是在執行國家給我的職務,因為我從來沒有失手,所以並沒有失手的選擇。8964 copyright protection392PENANAKYppjtC2j9 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAdHF9flgKHY
8964 copyright protection392PENANAGHRqPaKHgz 維尼
「軍人殺人,若果有錯嘅話,係邊個嘅錯?」教授一話道出我心中的疑問。8964 copyright protection392PENANAEg3ecKymYS 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAysl40L4m5W
8964 copyright protection392PENANAu8RGJ0E5Od 維尼
「軍人。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAigapXWuE0r 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAhJe5g72swz
8964 copyright protection392PENANAJh9U5f1C3U 維尼
「國家。」我也回應。8964 copyright protection392PENANAlhdBdfoUMp 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA2pYP8gaWgY
8964 copyright protection392PENANAxod16C2X9z 維尼
「部隊。」8964 copyright protection392PENANA159Zhg5x4M 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAfRIQ9iFXQO
8964 copyright protection392PENANAwHLHzY1MM0 維尼
「長官。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAqckLugTvEh 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANALxpnivVe2W
8964 copyright protection392PENANApV9k3TtZFS 維尼
軍人殺人的話,當然是下達指令的長官要負上責任吧。8964 copyright protection392PENANAg6csRMsyKm 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANASKqpzVAf42
8964 copyright protection392PENANAW6VUVqqQIk 維尼
「軍人的父母。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAmPMYADoT7P 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANASMX9srnBbs
8964 copyright protection392PENANABGQ0C5VFG3 維尼
「軍火商。」8964 copyright protection392PENANA5Blgi5al3H 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAWtUcHJx6fS
8964 copyright protection392PENANAAOPq48I5jV 維尼
「教育制度。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAnexQ4mh3yZ 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAFbsATJTdLB
8964 copyright protection392PENANA7K1tojB5I2 維尼
「社會運作形式。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAgPdvPKjWVZ 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAe8Dc38uipl
8964 copyright protection392PENANApcMHHvPzSD 維尼
「普世價值。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAr3IZ4LWhIj 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA01iPhKUj57
8964 copyright protection392PENANAgPvEmGjseN 維尼
「金錢。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAfbPT101VMi 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAaKqNU1dG0l
8964 copyright protection392PENANA3aJd0tz8wC 維尼
「歷史。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAgqjkkrpkQ9 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAciXMzE58ON
8964 copyright protection392PENANAOUQpPZguHY 維尼
「被殺者。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAucxyk2AD5E 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA6dEDnHG6yU
8964 copyright protection392PENANAOXzisx1Zji 維尼
各種答案也反映了各人思考背後採用的推論方式。8964 copyright protection392PENANA4zjXfwlx6X 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAHNv4hjxPY2
8964 copyright protection392PENANACNd7sM0ogq 維尼
教授笑了笑,續道:「或者我地換個角度諗,邊一個要負上最大責任?」8964 copyright protection392PENANAgpEdJ9p3VU 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANALZK1AOQh9t
8964 copyright protection392PENANArEDNwQIrcF 維尼
「軍人。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAWPuFcMYf6w 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAJeS8mYbRYT
8964 copyright protection392PENANAvOFr0lKPwf 維尼
「國家。」8964 copyright protection392PENANA42jMvPdbzf 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAO2Jb2OvS09
8964 copyright protection392PENANAnr8RhqhhYH 維尼
「國家。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAS8TybRXw9R 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAB7G0rGd7FZ
8964 copyright protection392PENANAcbY2Utz8oz 維尼
「軍人。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAkhhy8rizRH 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAai7DWUSV8h
8964 copyright protection392PENANAZpw1IkUrK9 維尼
「軍人。」8964 copyright protection392PENANAGPtn5NXhNe 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAcuWagq3Wb4
8964 copyright protection392PENANAzprOtDafA7 維尼
班上分成了「軍人」與「國家」兩派,「軍人」派的話相信是認為軍人是最終執行者,而「國家」派的話相信是認為國家是最大的決策者。8964 copyright protection392PENANAAO6BYxrOyL 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAEedBXLFEWe
8964 copyright protection392PENANAbaq0Nr7ev6 維尼
前者為因果論,某程度上來說是自由意志主義的信奉者,他們相信軍人有最後的權利決定執行「殺戮」與否。8964 copyright protection392PENANAPJM3fUAmVn 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA85Vdktvh6C
8964 copyright protection392PENANAusE9ZJcSCQ 維尼
普通的軍人,軍命如山,更何況不殺人就會被人殺死,更何況是一個軍隊養大的少年,哪有甚麼狗屁自由意志?8964 copyright protection392PENANAybrLwHQlfn 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAClDc1Haf3s
8964 copyright protection392PENANA5EDfj5LsOE 維尼
媽的,一群生於安穩幸福之中的書呆子。8964 copyright protection392PENANAMv6SUV0Dm0 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAcXTKqEZ98S
8964 copyright protection392PENANA4quHmfrDQ7 維尼
「就算一個軍人放過左一個目標,唔通國家唔會派另一堆軍人嚟殺死目標?結果根本無改變,國家有好多手段殺死一個人,而軍人只不過係國家殺人嘅其中一種手段。」我發言。8964 copyright protection392PENANAnMtUc6EmS2 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAsVGWjCjs6I
8964 copyright protection392PENANA52I00IM403 維尼
「留意番,宜家我地只係討論緊一個擁有自由意志嘅個體軍人,佢殺人有冇錯。」那名眼鏡少女說。8964 copyright protection392PENANAInElAh1La1 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAGzwPZ7xUys
8964 copyright protection392PENANAOBkSRy8O8p 維尼
「既然目標都係要死喺國家命令之下,由邊個執行都冇分別,所以最大責任喺國家度。」我回應。8964 copyright protection392PENANATlQIA3flPk 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAoGb1pwUIol
8964 copyright protection392PENANAUfSzLx2oP0 維尼
「軍人有自由意志將槍口提高幾厘米。」少女回應。8964 copyright protection392PENANAjK0DiG1NNG 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA9XSF93zjcw
8964 copyright protection392PENANAGhaO7yZKix 維尼
「你係話,軍人有自由意志被人殺死?若果面對生命威脅嘅時刻,普世價值仲適用?」我反駁。8964 copyright protection392PENANArYviuVwqaX 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAxElPIW5H64
8964 copyright protection392PENANADw2Ri2pJLE 維尼
「……」少女無言以對。8964 copyright protection392PENANA41b97H7mS8 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAKo8kz4TJ1A
8964 copyright protection392PENANAFP6Ilotc12 維尼
……8964 copyright protection392PENANAAXyUoLmWPG 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA88tstEmDBl
8964 copyright protection392PENANAM9mTONfiBi 維尼
但作為狙擊手的時候,其實面對的風險相對較小。8964 copyright protection392PENANApkY3jJnxR5 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAblfRLiPAsy
8964 copyright protection392PENANAIo2tBUv2Zk 維尼
那麽我擁有自由意志之時,依照軍令殺人又是否一件錯事?8964 copyright protection392PENANAXxttuP3QdJ 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANAl4dtYt64OO
8964 copyright protection392PENANAtD7GPxwkmq 維尼
A是8964 copyright protection392PENANAZWJ5m9P9dR 維尼
B不是8964 copyright protection392PENANANChifFZKOL 維尼
396Please respect copyright.PENANA00Zj2txBtN
3.145.75.74
ns3.145.75.74da2