Chapter Two: The Flesh Beneath the Robes
They were men.9Please respect copyright.PENANArkTMqXIfN7
Long before they were priests, they were men.
And inside the whitewashed walls of the convent, when the incense faded and the faithful had gone home—the rituals became routine, and the temptations bled through.
Not every priest was corrupt.9Please respect copyright.PENANAHVJDOIwaLo
But not every priest was clean.
Father Ely had long known this. He’d seen it too many times, especially in confession rooms that doubled as therapy booths for his fellow clergy. They came to him not just to confess—but to vent, to justify, to seek forgiveness without change.
“Forgive me, Father, for I slept with another sacristan. He said he was twenty—he wasn’t.”9Please respect copyright.PENANAtrUbF0V3LA
“Forgive me, Father, I took church money again. Just a little. For my dying mother. And a new iPhone.”9Please respect copyright.PENANAukjLXUV81s
“Forgive me, Father, I was in Solaire last night. Baccarat was flowing. So was the wine. I wore my collar under my jacket. It made the waitresses nervous.”
Some were secret drinkers.9Please respect copyright.PENANAqGhsNxtbzt
Others had private Grindr accounts under fake names.9Please respect copyright.PENANAfwqb9ZCMrz
A few kept women in apartments rented from the university funds.
They joked about it in whispers.9Please respect copyright.PENANAaLArZxmQ4h
Called themselves the "Brotherhood of Flesh."9Please respect copyright.PENANAEr3cxRF2TD
A mocking nod to the vows they all broke in some way.
They weren’t all predators.9Please respect copyright.PENANAvOWX9CdyN3
But some were.
There was Fr. Lino, soft-spoken, fond of young choir boys. He never touched them—no. But the way his hand lingered on shoulders, the extra-long “spiritual retreats” he scheduled with his favorite boys—everyone knew. But no one reported him.
Because in San Bartolome, you don’t expose a priest.9Please respect copyright.PENANAjEPcwZZXpy
You protect the image, even if it kills the truth.
“We are shepherds,” the Prior once said in a closed-door meeting. “And shepherds must sometimes keep the flock in line—by silence.”
That silence was golden.9Please respect copyright.PENANAvbkdDy3dsw
It funded casinos.9Please respect copyright.PENANAweloFqneCj
It protected reputations.9Please respect copyright.PENANAdMjLbkE57L
It buried scandals like corpses under marble floors.
Even Father Ely—the one they called the golden boy—had secrets.9Please respect copyright.PENANAPwIFlxGIzs
He didn’t touch children. He didn’t steal. He didn’t gamble.
But he was lonely.9Please respect copyright.PENANAw6pVi1qWmN
Deeply. Quietly.9Please respect copyright.PENANA4sgrrD45sy
And sometimes that loneliness took the shape of a sin he refused to name aloud.
That was before Ella Martinez walked into the confession room.9Please respect copyright.PENANA0drzKQbP6q
Before her voice—shaky, soft, braver than most—asked him something that unsettled his soul.
“Father, what happens when you want to believe… but the people of God are the ones hurting you?”
Ely couldn’t answer right away.
Because her voice reminded him of something he buried.9Please respect copyright.PENANA0IRU23ybB2
Because he, too, once asked that same question—9Please respect copyright.PENANAuOrk0AgiFr
Only difference was… no one answered him.