濤臥市東行七里,有地名「破問丘」,舊為語者修行之地,如今滿地荒草,碑倒樹裂。傳聞當年一語者於此破心自焚,自後便再無人敢語於此地。49Please respect copyright.PENANASOjqylNKTC
49Please respect copyright.PENANAb7uIV11cqc
林慧芳立於坡上,手執筆冊,不語不動。此行無目標,亦無敵人,卻令她心中難寧。風聲拂過耳畔,宛如舊語迴響,讓人分不清現實與記憶。49Please respect copyright.PENANAz1bSjqVRTe
49Please respect copyright.PENANAIIuUPGv8qo
楚紅練翻閱地圖,淡聲道:“這裡在問界之內,但宗門皆不列入圖中,因其——曾有人於此破相。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAgWyDgubMjb
49Please respect copyright.PENANAlIEwIrQDTU
無名走至碑前,指間拂過斷裂碑文,低聲念出:「語生無聲,問斷無痕。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAtso13xuuQq
49Please respect copyright.PENANAlYXKqCtksc
林慧芳聞言,冊上筆尖輕點,寫下此句。49Please respect copyright.PENANAneDlnG0ek1
49Please respect copyright.PENANA8JzLS8lMr7
她忽然想起塵飛揚曾說過一句話,那是在舊日山中夜談時他隨口念出,當時她並未在意,如今卻宛如迴音自心底湧現:49Please respect copyright.PENANAJpbwLycfnz
49Please respect copyright.PENANAbA42YkEkjj
——「有些話不是說出口才算語,有些問,是連自己都不敢寫下的東西。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAVj9xkouXPu
49Please respect copyright.PENANAZ4HIfF5l1z
她輕輕在冊中記下那句話旁,寫道:49Please respect copyright.PENANARNYk35Mi1d
49Please respect copyright.PENANAz5yyfL7HrR
——「心中有問,未必能語,筆之所至,不敢落字者,是真問。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAXqcaxWMDro
49Please respect copyright.PENANABUs8mAk0F5
語未開,筆未落,三人步入破問丘深處。49Please respect copyright.PENANAHKi9ZV7CwZ
49Please respect copyright.PENANAwtXhdzgkky
丘間有陣,不為宗門設,只為舊語者遺留之心。忽有微霧升起,林間浮現一排無人之影,靜立如石,嘴唇微動,卻無聲可聽。49Please respect copyright.PENANAXfSiiQlewp
49Please respect copyright.PENANABr3yqzNmh9
無名低語:“語影。曾經說過的話,未被聽見,便成了殘影。”49Please respect copyright.PENANASwsgWBKZQ3
49Please respect copyright.PENANAzAF6kM35Gu
林慧芳屏息,提筆欲記,忽感心頭震盪——那些語影中有一人,口型竟與她破語前最後一次嘲語一致:49Please respect copyright.PENANAynGb9NEUnZ
49Please respect copyright.PENANAz4QUcCQPgr
“誰說話多砍不了人?”49Please respect copyright.PENANAzczT3Z4WQW
49Please respect copyright.PENANAzSd29hjcpY
她身形一頓,未言,筆卻停滯半空。49Please respect copyright.PENANATK1g50DTOY
49Please respect copyright.PENANAqw8SQD7UeD
楚紅練橫劍守後,冷聲道:“幻象,會問你不想答的話。”49Please respect copyright.PENANA8stUUwq3NL
49Please respect copyright.PENANATrLeJ9GCbR
無名轉首,望向她,語聲沉穩:“若她能不語而過,這陣,自破。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAcleoHbUN6A
49Please respect copyright.PENANAeaS33BvXPz
林慧芳閉目,心中千語交疊,終只筆下一語:49Please respect copyright.PENANAyxSnrnZNXn
49Please respect copyright.PENANAMhaEGA5JqM
——「語之殘影,問我舊我;我不答,不是無語,是因不再是她。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAgzvB6kPb6v
49Please respect copyright.PENANA3hBAg56533
筆落那瞬,語影如風中碎塵,紛紛散去。49Please respect copyright.PENANA1Qydw3brwQ
49Please respect copyright.PENANAlgqpeTxVr2
問心之地,無聲而過。49Please respect copyright.PENANAe6I3WzF9NZ
49Please respect copyright.PENANAR1XkHKLgy8
她第一次明白,不說話,不是忍耐,而是選擇。49Please respect copyright.PENANA7StQbJ15SU
49Please respect copyright.PENANAdxIzyM1NHW
這,才是真正的筆問之始。49Please respect copyright.PENANAv6rGadqVfD
49Please respect copyright.PENANAquzdISkpvd
49Please respect copyright.PENANAeaEyBkZLEj
霧散之後,破問丘盡頭現出一片澤地,水靜無波,草低如歸。49Please respect copyright.PENANAfJuoQpj99v
49Please respect copyright.PENANAqvieMTxg49
林慧芳踏水而行,足不濕履。她感到一種異樣寧靜,那不是幻,也不是術,而是一種「語意未生之地」。49Please respect copyright.PENANAA0SMFDHhe0
49Please respect copyright.PENANAX2eDedZB8S
無名在一旁低語:“這片澤,名『無問潭』。據說曾有問者心斷於此,自此之後無人再問。”49Please respect copyright.PENANANQB10AEpmF
49Please respect copyright.PENANAknUgeDvM50
楚紅練問:“怎會斷於此?”49Please respect copyright.PENANABzGVh9AsQE
49Please respect copyright.PENANAxnmYW8j34z
無名答:“因其問非己問。所問之語,皆為他人所需,他人之解。”49Please respect copyright.PENANASNq5AHAjau
49Please respect copyright.PENANAPyvmdpFfWR
林慧芳心有所感,在冊上寫下:49Please respect copyright.PENANAfrAhM8Qo6o
49Please respect copyright.PENANASbhzk3nD4U
——「若語非己問,則語為假聲。若筆為己記,筆即為真語。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAnPfAixMY3M
49Please respect copyright.PENANAQsazspZCXQ
他們沿著潭邊前行,忽見岸邊浮現一道石碑,碑上未有字,卻有刀痕九道,深淺不一,似斷非斷。49Please respect copyright.PENANA55a85EQLtn
49Please respect copyright.PENANAX6v1svQjzJ
“這不是筆痕。”楚紅練沉聲道,“是刀問。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAkqg08lDXqm
49Please respect copyright.PENANA9gZFCkU1pf
林慧芳頓悟,這可能正是塵飛揚當年筆下未記的地方。49Please respect copyright.PENANABTG3MLHBLd
49Please respect copyright.PENANAPQ9KZ0LjvM
她記起他曾有語,笑言:「若我之刀能問,那我所不斷之處,就是我之答案。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAxUDqwoGLgr
49Please respect copyright.PENANAyjsFjzvR3F
林慧芳伏地而記,筆落三語:49Please respect copyright.PENANAl7opz3m38G
49Please respect copyright.PENANAoTocmQaLum
——「語不一定能問,刀未必不能。」 49Please respect copyright.PENANAbqHk3A0OFH
——「所問非語,亦可為心。」 49Please respect copyright.PENANASQQ2ANfQDC
——「未說之語,非無語,是語尚未生。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAVunWfWEwlb
49Please respect copyright.PENANAM0fJAKN1P6
就在此刻,潭水忽起波紋,一道幻影自水中浮現——並非敵,亦非影,而是一段語句,懸於水氣之中:49Please respect copyright.PENANAe5fuF14Mbk
49Please respect copyright.PENANAoAUVJAtldK
——「若你所言,不為人聽,你還說嗎?」49Please respect copyright.PENANAFsjk80xEOt
49Please respect copyright.PENANAaIirxEWWSy
林慧芳筆未動,心已震。49Please respect copyright.PENANAfkVMWv0v2V
49Please respect copyright.PENANAh8HLxuloFY
這不是外敵之問,是心中長埋未發的「反問」。49Please respect copyright.PENANAkkKJsT2aEq
49Please respect copyright.PENANA16SqJPc5ke
她沉思良久,終於低聲開口,聲音微若浮塵:49Please respect copyright.PENANAXOock5QrFG
49Please respect copyright.PENANAxxGxxAtmes
“我曾說,是為了不被忘。如今……我不說,是為了不再忘了我自己。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAfRmEymAw9g
49Please respect copyright.PENANABDPTr38He7
語落,幻字沉水,水面如初。49Please respect copyright.PENANAEEoPkRUpOL
49Please respect copyright.PENANAuKccuj4mdd
楚紅練未語,卻望她一眼,那眼神中,有一抹未說出的敬意。49Please respect copyright.PENANA80xyLlKmpR
49Please respect copyright.PENANAsFlTGQ2dDm
林慧芳緩緩合上冊頁,語未生,問已至。49Please respect copyright.PENANAfyxmz2s8eE
49Please respect copyright.PENANAbzdppLr7SG
這片潭,雖無聲,卻是她自筆問以來,真正踏出的第一個答案。49Please respect copyright.PENANA7s5AEFaP87
49Please respect copyright.PENANAydnVyiQAb9
49Please respect copyright.PENANA9wNjs1AHPq
暮色將至,三人走出無問潭,前方林間現一拱門殘構,殘門上鐫有三字:49Please respect copyright.PENANAsys8PIqLUE
49Please respect copyright.PENANASu3xgfLF1o
——「心問界」49Please respect copyright.PENANArUWX7ZU6Rs
49Please respect copyright.PENANA6bXJjmDDk9
無名眉心微蹙:“這是舊日語者設下的幻陣邊界,問心為陣,不應輕入。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAV0mmQBUC5U
49Please respect copyright.PENANAbHRai0HoAV
楚紅練不語,只以劍點地,試探氣機。忽有氣流如風而非風,從拱門之內緩緩湧出,帶著微弱語意殘痕。49Please respect copyright.PENANAT7MtJHtTeT
49Please respect copyright.PENANANlzTAlS2di
林慧芳凝視那殘門,筆冊未開,卻以心感受。49Please respect copyright.PENANAx2gvKaHSJd
49Please respect copyright.PENANARz9bHnkn3B
那氣息不是敵意,而是一種未竟的語,一種「欲言未語」的存在。她靜坐原地,開始記錄:49Please respect copyright.PENANAnPwsIQTZ8x
49Please respect copyright.PENANAQeXqRFiTx9
——「此氣非術,非聲,似問而未言,似語而不生。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAUTVZp84BQt
49Please respect copyright.PENANAkVyzWNtI8J
——「其問不為破人,而為尋己。」49Please respect copyright.PENANA6wnWAxAkxK
49Please respect copyright.PENANA4ZydAFH3ud
三人尚未進門,幻陣已自開。49Please respect copyright.PENANANOkmzadu0H
49Please respect copyright.PENANADPHCjGEvR1
門內無光,僅有語影浮動,如無主之思,在空中遊移、沉浮、反覆述說——49Please respect copyright.PENANAg1FFAXLo8o
49Please respect copyright.PENANApyID2gZDyt
“我說的話,誰聽見了?” 49Please respect copyright.PENANAfZOo18f96x
“若說出口無人回應,那還算語嗎?” 49Please respect copyright.PENANAor7Ae1Dtsc
“我聽見自己了嗎?” 49Please respect copyright.PENANAZJ36eXfS3u
“還是只是模仿他人?”49Please respect copyright.PENANAzPIJzO4otb
49Please respect copyright.PENANAmkXxJnKM2e
這些不是幻象語者之術,而是「被語所遺留者」的心聲——未被問完之人、未被聽見之語。49Please respect copyright.PENANAYjPtY81CPV
49Please respect copyright.PENANAtC2kUqYVU3
林慧芳走入幻中,語冊在手,筆未曾停。49Please respect copyright.PENANAM5rhFwvbuI
49Please respect copyright.PENANA7hnrKS38NC
她一邊走,一邊書寫每一句心聲,不為記錄術法,不為分析敵人,只是為了「讓這些語存在過」。49Please respect copyright.PENANAKKmDZPTQGV
49Please respect copyright.PENANAnTT14fCDKZ
她落筆一語:49Please respect copyright.PENANAa1X4m34onK
49Please respect copyright.PENANA4bxporn9EH
——「有人說過話,就值得被記下;哪怕說的人,從未被聽見。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAMi7kJA3C0C
49Please respect copyright.PENANAvuCIphtjNg
無名望著她背影,低聲自問:“若所有語都需回音,那最初說話的人,是不是早已靜默?”49Please respect copyright.PENANAuJM7Bohm8l
49Please respect copyright.PENANAQwyljOf2ee
楚紅練跟上,心中起伏不定。49Please respect copyright.PENANAibG578dyZJ
49Please respect copyright.PENANAhxfQuEpW2B
這片幻界,不是戰場,也不是語術陣,而是「語所遺留」的世界,是語者死後,問未完之地。49Please respect copyright.PENANAhNsaJSeGKT
49Please respect copyright.PENANAiPSuMr6CAB
他們踏入的不只是幻境,而是一個問題: 49Please respect copyright.PENANA18GoACGM0N
——「語者死後,其問猶在,那誰來回答?」49Please respect copyright.PENANANjjeLGSUgS
49Please respect copyright.PENANAadqruvAiDZ
林慧芳未回首,只筆落其後。她知道,這片地,無須破,須記。49Please respect copyright.PENANAIS1651cbgJ
49Please respect copyright.PENANAjjVMmtTBvQ
此問,不為答,而為聽。49Please respect copyright.PENANAM1fGtuoXcK
49Please respect copyright.PENANAT2obwyfXEq
49Please respect copyright.PENANATnaQ0khgE6
幻境深處,語聲不斷卻無實體,三人如行於無形問流之中,每一步皆有語句擦肩而過。49Please respect copyright.PENANAM69G0HuIUF
49Please respect copyright.PENANAdhPLSgNNYr
楚紅練忽然止步,眉頭緊鎖。她前方浮現一道虛影,影中之人並無面貌,卻持劍而立,劍尖直指她心口,嘴唇微動。49Please respect copyright.PENANAMc8YDrLFkp
49Please respect copyright.PENANA6iHtU8trnu
林慧芳筆記間見到其唇語:49Please respect copyright.PENANAcYwwzfDKAw
49Please respect copyright.PENANAXaAWEMhfms
——「妳的劍,斷得了自己的問嗎?」49Please respect copyright.PENANAW5J8bW5ytL
49Please respect copyright.PENANAoU2o0CSP7d
楚紅練一怔,反射拔劍迎上,劍氣掃破虛影,卻如斬入風中,無所依憑。語聲再響:49Please respect copyright.PENANAa8em0Otkcu
49Please respect copyright.PENANAyMesv7xYdi
——「劍斷人,劍斷語,唯不可斷心。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAdCnYPqeRZw
49Please respect copyright.PENANAOKY2IeLD2D
她握劍之手微顫,不是恐懼,而是懷疑:她修劍一生,卻從未問過劍是否為她而生,還是她為劍而活。49Please respect copyright.PENANAjHdaH5Orc1
49Please respect copyright.PENANADcgeeeyXB8
無名開口:“那不是在攻妳,是妳自己曾說過的話。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAcZhF7vRULu
49Please respect copyright.PENANAPoujG3gsTP
楚紅練低語:“我從未說過這句。”49Please respect copyright.PENANA8dUsNrwoZp
49Please respect copyright.PENANARk6pGm7kmO
林慧芳走近,在冊頁上寫下一語:49Please respect copyright.PENANAUSXZKRF4Vh
49Please respect copyright.PENANA8OfSJoHs7B
——「若幻中之語我未說過,卻能刺我之心,或許是我未敢說的。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAp9mt3ejD6Q
49Please respect copyright.PENANAXPSDMHnpj4
她輕輕放下筆,對楚紅練道:“妳劍很快,但心太慢。不是動作,而是妳還沒讓它問過妳自己。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAJ5t7gBx0EQ
49Please respect copyright.PENANAZG6SqQR6nQ
楚紅練沉默,收劍,抬頭望向空無之影,那影未散,只靜靜站著,不再發問。49Please respect copyright.PENANAlnHYMQT350
49Please respect copyright.PENANAm0tRmwqZXy
這一刻,楚紅練未再出劍,也未答問,但她心中生出第一個關於自己的疑問:49Please respect copyright.PENANAqw8OWHXvIq
49Please respect copyright.PENANAxWfBa1zvUW
——「我,是誰的劍?」49Please respect copyright.PENANAG1YamE3nN6
49Please respect copyright.PENANAAOv7xi2snW
幻境沉寂,三人再度前行,林慧芳筆未停,書下:49Please respect copyright.PENANA1QtdIeMSUW
49Please respect copyright.PENANAD6cbrmkIEd
——「語不語皆為問,劍不斬亦能傷。心若未問,萬語皆虛。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAPlcyMRxjRE
49Please respect copyright.PENANAuqoPQFs4Fr
風起無聲,幻影隱退。49Please respect copyright.PENANAeON1VojTeS
49Please respect copyright.PENANAgwegMRZcpt
問心無聲之境,不是讓人說出真話,而是讓人第一次知道:自己有話沒說。49Please respect copyright.PENANADjSGATZCxG
49Please respect copyright.PENANALKkPcS6Id5
那不是謊言,而是未敢問的沉默。49Please respect copyright.PENANAjt4pzqBs1g
49Please respect copyright.PENANAfE64aXVsIS
49Please respect copyright.PENANAxeeAAP4S9n
幻境終點,是一道無形之牆,牆上無門、無縫、無字。49Please respect copyright.PENANAJha1xSmGhx
49Please respect copyright.PENANAS1gGtjubo0
三人立於前,語聲已止,幻影已散,唯獨此牆如一問未成。49Please respect copyright.PENANAkoeAN4JH20
49Please respect copyright.PENANAqt2eEE8ju4
林慧芳望之良久,未試以筆破,也未以語試探,只靜靜站著,似在等待。49Please respect copyright.PENANAvWXMT0tSeB
49Please respect copyright.PENANALoZvYCEj2A
無名輕聲說道:“這牆不是障,是一問。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAZdhtHjNYnc
49Please respect copyright.PENANAht4c0tTrOT
楚紅練蹙眉:“問什麼?”49Please respect copyright.PENANAVrbfSIolrP
49Please respect copyright.PENANAlL14FDvRhu
無名答:“問你是否還有話,是對你自己說的,但你從未說出口。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAPFp8mkqWGo
49Please respect copyright.PENANAAtStgeRdOC
林慧芳緩緩展開筆冊,書至最後一頁,留白已久。她凝視那一頁良久,筆落無字。49Please respect copyright.PENANADV5gUuDBPg
49Please respect copyright.PENANAHZlzfvSt1d
她寫下:49Please respect copyright.PENANAPpoW44qQLE
49Please respect copyright.PENANAQcckAQoWaA
——「此頁為我,未能自問之語留。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAPZHzOL12qF
49Please respect copyright.PENANAgp4jgdeSrI
她將筆冊闔上,不再嘗試破陣,轉身而行。49Please respect copyright.PENANAUB2SVAQuwC
49Please respect copyright.PENANAgClRfxp4ZC
那一刻,無形之牆如霧散開,一道通路顯現。49Please respect copyright.PENANAYGxiiDIIq9
49Please respect copyright.PENANAvMRm7Ngpqh
楚紅練怔住:“她什麼也沒說,也沒破……就過去了?”49Please respect copyright.PENANAv4YVg891zI
49Please respect copyright.PENANAbSFJNb4onB
無名回道:“她破的,不是牆,是她自己還未能寫下的那一句。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAhbM8WVqzxi
49Please respect copyright.PENANAGEi2LF4bwJ
三人走出幻陣,身後幻境收斂如水,無聲沉沒。49Please respect copyright.PENANAtqlylwsytU
49Please respect copyright.PENANAtVs9ldFqE6
破問丘之外,天已破曉。49Please respect copyright.PENANAvbWqYtnbVb
49Please respect copyright.PENANArZNiK03MP1
林慧芳回首,心中無語,筆中無問,卻覺胸中輕盈。49Please respect copyright.PENANAIIj3SFr234
49Please respect copyright.PENANAxENjtisJyG
她明白了一件事——語術從來不是為了讓別人理解,而是讓自己不再害怕問。49Please respect copyright.PENANAcb6n0UexxK
49Please respect copyright.PENANAl1ilbKjuDq
她低語一句,聲音輕若風:49Please respect copyright.PENANAFJIUAS652B
49Please respect copyright.PENANA5amxYkneBs
“問不是答案,是我還敢再寫的那一筆。”49Please respect copyright.PENANAR359jqmCTM
49Please respect copyright.PENANArirvJHx42h
無名微笑點頭,楚紅練靜靜不語。49Please respect copyright.PENANAjcJAJwdo6F
49Please respect copyright.PENANAUXPeIIn8Td
筆記翻至新頁,林慧芳寫下:49Please respect copyright.PENANA29GC56Wcnr
49Please respect copyright.PENANAHkzyOKxR9e
——「此章為我,無聲而問。」49Please respect copyright.PENANAuVR1bX0Hrg
49Please respect copyright.PENANA4rzAXmgp3r
而此段旅程,也成了她筆下《筆中問》的第一篇真正無聲的章。49Please respect copyright.PENANALzyvz0r3Gz
49Please respect copyright.PENANANJdMsS6SIi
語無聲,問猶在。49Please respect copyright.PENANAp4ApL9fu0R
49Please respect copyright.PENANAsSgledrnSu
問心無聲,卻最為清晰。49Please respect copyright.PENANAoWaiaMXrLW
49Please respect copyright.PENANAR5yNs1pkFn
49Please respect copyright.PENANAYkqYqWc53g
林慧芳完成了《筆中問》的第一篇章,不以語破敵、不為人書法,而是為了真正將自己的疑問留下一筆。問心無聲,卻最為真實。語者之路,在無聲之地,終於啟程。
49Please respect copyright.PENANA4axfdqImzU
第二十三章:完
ns216.73.216.72da2