Living With Killers {A Darkened Hearts FanFic} - Chapter Five: That Was Unexpected | Penana

Please use Chrome or Firefox for better user experience!
Living With Killers {A Darkened Hearts FanFic}
Writer ToriHeadWolf
  • G: General Audiences
  • PG: Parental Guidance Suggested
  • PG-13: Parents Strongly Cautioned
  • R: Restricted
737 Reads

Facebook · Twitter

FAQ · Feedback · Privacy · Terms

Penana © 2018

Get it on Google Play

Download on the App Store

Follow Author
Living With Killers {A Darkened Hearts FanFic}
A - A - A
Chapter Five: That Was Unexpected
Nov 29, 2016
15 Mins Read
No Plagiarism!SOwOfTcV6sW0RJy71NGtposted on PENANA

Murder. The one thing I never expected myself to do. And here I am, about to kill one more person. I’m also accompanied by a murderer. But if I had to tell the truth, I really didn’t mind Liu coming along. But there’s a slight problem with him coming; I’m not sure...but I’m quite positive I have….feelings for him. Oh shizz.copyright protection116PENANAQCXiPkWW4h

I pretend that I don’t, acting as though I go murder people every day. I failed. I failed miserably. I mean, I guess it’s pretty obvious I like him, but I think it’s too obvious. Shit. This is starting to sound like a diary.copyright protection116PENANAVW5sLklXgs

“You okay?” Liu’s voice breaks me out of my trance.copyright protection116PENANAqdshW0pYO5

“Y-yeah. Just...thinking,” I reply.copyright protection116PENANAsFHpXxJUtO

“About what?”copyright protection116PENANAbpLgRwBduR

I know that I can’t tell him what I was really thinking about. “Killing Jaye. I know he deserves it, but I’m just not used to this.” I hated lying, but I really didn’t want him knowing the truth either. copyright protection116PENANAFV48d19CZX

“You’ll be fine. Trust me,” Liu assures me, but I didn’t believe him. He drapes his arm around my shoulders.copyright protection116PENANAIsDqRBXBvr

“Sure,” I mutter as we walk back towards Jaye’s house. Liu gives me a confused look, but doesn’t say anything. When we reach the house, I finally get a good look at it for the first time.copyright protection116PENANApGQbXIHyVc

It was a mansion, obviously, but the white paint was faded and chipping off. The windows didn’t have curtains and the glass had several cracks. It looked like it’d been through hell. And who knows, maybe it has.copyright protection116PENANApB7uJlvTXv

Liu and I walked right up to it and entered the mansion like we owned the place. There in the center of the hall sat a chair. In the chair, sat Jaye. The chair was set so that it was backwards. We walked up the chair and flipped it around.copyright protection116PENANARFXu5P53qA

Jaye was dead. Someone fucking beat me to it! His throat had been slit and his eyes were missing. He also had a hole in his sides… right where his kidneys would be… Then it hit me. Jack killed Jaye. But why?? copyright protection116PENANAuQhl1e3JNZ

I suddenly felt so livid; I felt as though I could kill anything. I stared at Jaye’s slightly mutilated body with disgust.copyright protection116PENANAWdB3Hlocem

I suddenly grinned before cracking up with laughter, “I should go ahead and finish up the job…”copyright protection116PENANAI52GA8vFbW

Liu stared at me, “T-Tori..? What are you…?”copyright protection116PENANAgGNy1PM4yA

I kicked Jaye’s body off the chair and lunged at it. My vision blurred as I repeatedly stabbed and mutilated Jaye’s body even further.copyright protection116PENANA4uNFyu1XHf

“TORI!” Liu grabbed my arms to pull me back, but I elbowed him. Instead, he wraps his arms around my waist and finally yanks me off of Jaye’s mutilated corpse.copyright protection116PENANAkplm6VuBAG

“NO! I’M NOT FINISHED YET!!” I scream, but Liu doesn’t let me go.copyright protection116PENANAyRmlpobctK

“Stop! He’s dead enough!” He shouts. I eventually dropped my arms, the machetes slipping out of my hands and landing on the blood-splattered floor.copyright protection116PENANAMxfzdN3eLL

My shirt was covered in blood, and my already stained shorts were soaked. My black hair hung in my face, and I reached up to brush it away with blood-covered fingers. I broke out of Liu’s grasp and crumpled to the ground. I’m a monster, I’m a monster, I kept telling myself, which only made the situation worse.copyright protection116PENANAu5bPrhKWTl

“Tori? You alright?” Liu crouches down next to me, a concerned look on his stitched face.copyright protection116PENANADrc0NCoYOR

I nod and shake my head repeatedly, not sure if I am alright or not. I eventually said, “I’m not okay, Liu. I can’t believe I just did that! I’m a monster!”copyright protection116PENANAIBpXaCLeRw

Liu seems taken aback by my response. “No you’re not, Tori. You’re just a normal Creepypasta. This is what we do..just not like this. Pretty much Sarah is the only one who does this. Well, and Kaitlyn.”copyright protection116PENANA0mCbb3sW0l

Once again, he pulls me into a hug. Wow, I’ve gotten a lot of hugs from him today. I guess that’s a good thing. “You're not a monster, Tori. You’re just… like me when I started out.”copyright protection116PENANAhDNuDA71zW

I pulled away from him and looked at him, “What do you mean ‘when you started out’?”copyright protection116PENANAThxifIV0XM

Liu winced. “I… I was full of hatred towards Jeff… He killed our parents and tried to kill me. And to make it worse, he killed Jane’s family in front of her and tried to make her like him.” Liu explained.copyright protection116PENANAxX998kdBhd

“Oh my God,” I whispered, “Liu, I’m so, so sorry!”copyright protection116PENANAWyRJ3ukawU

“Don’t be,” Liu replied, “The past is in the past. Besides, I think we’re all a bit like that at the start… I mean, Sarah mutilated her ex’s body, LJ mutilated Isaac--”copyright protection116PENANA6qbEIrmDsj

“Who’s Isaac?” I asked.copyright protection116PENANAqZgz9pUm0b

“Isaac was LJ’s ‘owner’, well, more like the person he was created for and would develop, personality wise, as Isaac grew older… Isaac was pretty fucked up when he got older. Killed a woman and made a chair from her bones. LJ saw everything and thought it was a fun new game to play,” Liu chuckled, “Unfortunately for Isaac, he left LJ in his music box too long and once he got out, he made Isaac play the 'game' with him, resulting in Isaac’s death.”copyright protection116PENANAAXKsHNW2Yt

I shuddered, “Creepy…”copyright protection116PENANAW5T8KCz6f2

“Eh, he had fun!” Liu joked. I stared at him. He coughed, “Anyways, let’s head back, okay?”copyright protection116PENANAqG1Hgb6ay7

I nodded. “Okay, Liu.”copyright protection116PENANAl946BMUyOS

*~*copyright protection116PENANA1KYVSIysPO

We reached the mansion and parted our ways. Liu went to his room and I went to the living room and started watching Ouran Highschool Host Club with Sarah and Toby. I was chilling on the couch while they were cuddling on the loveseat. Once again, I felt jealous.copyright protection116PENANAufuwWKI3Vg

Liu then walked into the room and had an unfamiliar girl with him. The girl had dark auburn hair tied up in a ponytail and deep crimson eyes. Admittedly, she looked similar to John. I smiled at Liu.copyright protection116PENANAahpfn02hzQ

“Hey Liu!” I waved.copyright protection116PENANAaAB9wuR4XH

“So this is the new girl you told me about?” The new girl asked. Sarah looked up and saw Liu and the girl he was with.copyright protection116PENANATrWnYT8GX4

“Hey Liu! Hey NikNugget!” Sarah said with a grin before breaking into a fit of laughter, “Did you give John ‘the talk’?”copyright protection116PENANAX8lmnJnq1W

“Yeah,” The girl said, “He and Clockwork got so flushed! It was hilarious!”copyright protection116PENANAhcxSl4nd9k

“Yep…” John mutters while walking into the room, Clockwork right behind him.copyright protection116PENANAU2MRqKKzrH

“So..what’s your name?” I ask the girl standing next to Liu.copyright protection116PENANADoQZKdI8EK

She gives me a cold smile and replies, “Nikki. Nikki the Huntress. You’re Tori, right?” When I nod slowly, she adds, “Liu has told me about you.”copyright protection116PENANA5VWDOhHbvR

I looked at her confused, “He did?”copyright protection116PENANAvpThhj22St

“Yes,” Nikki said, her tone sounded normal but I could sense an edge to it. Nikki turned to Sarah and her face instantly lit up. It was pretty clear that these two get along really well. “So Sarah… I was wondering if you would care to be my Head Bridesmaid? And Sasha’s Godmother.”copyright protection116PENANAKwRAvCOeLs

Sarah’s eyes widened before she grinned, “Bruh. Do you even have to ask?”copyright protection116PENANAYQnVtbcbnI

“And Toby,” Liu said, “Nikki and I think it’d also be pretty appropriate if you were Sasha’s godfather as well, since you and Sarah are dating. Also, it’d be cool if you’d be one of my groomsmen. You sadly won’t be best man since Jeff literally begged me to let me do it since he let me--well, forced me to--be best man for his and Izzy’s wedding.”copyright protection116PENANA2T8Wbpfds8

“I’d love *twitch* to, Liu,” Toby said with a grin. That’s when it hit me. Liu was dating Nikki. Scratch that. He was getting married to Nikki. And she was pregnant with his child!copyright protection116PENANAHcFyMabBoW

“N-Nice… C-Congratulations!” I stuttered. I took a deep breath and stood up, “I-I need some air. See you guys l-later!” I quickly left before Sarah or anyone could say anything.copyright protection116PENANA3nNrihDvs0

I ran out into the woods and hid so no one could find me. I started to cry. For the first time in forever, I ended up liking a guy who is going to get married and is going to be a father.copyright protection116PENANAevUmr5LHie

I sat down under the tree and tried to keep my sobs as quiet as possible. I heard footsteps approach me, so I climbed the tree and perched on one of the lower hanging branches.copyright protection116PENANAQZqvydFKO4

“Tori!” A familiar-ish voice called out, “Tori! It’s me, Ash! Where are you, Tori? Everyone’s worried!” I looked down and saw Ash underneath me, searching around frantically.copyright protection116PENANAHSsukLLXge

I shifted to get down, when suddenly the branch gave out beneath me. “Gah!!” I cried as I came plummeting down.copyright protection116PENANAYuJTRbYDSh

Ash caught me with ease, albeit he got hit on the head with a falling branch. “You okay? You know you really shouldn’t be hanging out in trees…” Ash then cracked a smile, “Although, I guess you could say that you’re an angel because you fell from the sky.”copyright protection116PENANARIhhdPvTAj

“Smooth,” I said, “Did you just call me Satan?”copyright protection116PENANAYhcqLwbxus

Ash smiled, “Yes, yes I did.” I suddenly blushed, realizing how close our faces were. copyright protection116PENANAMtXvmOGlrz

Blush soon covered Ash’s face. “I’m sorry..” He mumbled before setting me back on the ground. “You… Uh… You fight good.”copyright protection116PENANACihTAvJ5pj

“Um.. thank you?” I asked. Ash just gave me a thumbs up before his face turned serious.copyright protection116PENANApnACOm80TD

“So… Uh… Tori..?” He cleared his throat before continuing, “I-I… God damn it… Why can’t I just say it?!” He swore under his breath. He shook his head, “I can’t say it.. But I kind of think this will speak more than words ever could…” Ash said before lightly putting his lips to mine.copyright protection116PENANAsF7qbueSPG

I stiffened up before slowly kissing him back. Ash seemed surprised, but happy. We soon parted and he was smiling.copyright protection116PENANArrZJkzf4EE

“So is that a yes?” He asked.copyright protection116PENANAn42XGQjPQd

“Yeah, I guess I’ll be your girlfriend.” I said, smiling softly.copyright protection116PENANAsjSAJ44YWU

“Great!” Ash said, his grin seemingly getting bigger. He chuckled softly, “Didn’t think I’d get this far…”copyright protection116PENANAEolD7GdmKS

“Why do you say that?” I asked.copyright protection116PENANA17W35DUosL

Ash shuffled his feet awkwardly, his blush getting worse. “I kinda thought you’d go for Eyeless…”copyright protection116PENANACV4uvOyANv

I shook my head, “No. You’re pretty cool.”copyright protection116PENANAusTP61wjog

Ash smiled, “You know, this is probably the happiest I’ve been since… ever.”copyright protection116PENANAbpo8tuLnSd

I looked up at him with a confused look on my face. Ash sighed.copyright protection116PENANA8v8dZE2yeP

“I’ve never really been much of a happy camper…” He ran a hand through his dark, ashen hair. “Kaitlyn, my cousin, was my only friend until we met Sarah. The three of us were unstoppable. Only getting time-outs when the teacher caught us selling legos on the playground.” Ash sighed and shook his head, “Then we met Austin, Zalgo’s precious little son, John and Nikki’s brother, and Sarah--” Ash stopped, “Wait, that’s not my story to tell.” He shook his head again, “Anyways, I did some stupid things that I regret deeply because of my emotions--or I guess lack of which...” Ash trailed off, lost in thought.copyright protection116PENANA4IhYynZ4Gn

“What kind of things?” I asked, curiosity clear in my voice.copyright protection116PENANAlSNK0heLF7

Ash shook his head, “Don’t worry about it.” He smiled at me. “Come on, let’s head back.”copyright protection116PENANAZOC71CM4b0

I followed Ash, not wanting to push any further. I mean, he is my boyfriend now. He’s bound to tell me on his own accord. Soon enough, we arrived at the mansion. Ash waved goodbye and went to his room and I went to the living room. I plopped down on the couch and turned the TV on.copyright protection116PENANATfIadhydlf

I changed the channel and found Fairy Tail. I started watching the characters go around with whatever problem had arisen. EJ suddenly came into the room and sat beside me.copyright protection116PENANAAH7or8FGUl

“So what’s up?” He asked me. I looked over at him and smiled.copyright protection116PENANANT9q1b2Nfd

“Hi. So, my name is..[Dan],” I reply, using the hand gestures Danisnotonfire used in his first video. Sarah then ran into the room and held out her hand.copyright protection116PENANAO8txjGOST9

“JOIN THE PHANDOM WITH ME TORI!!!” She shouts.copyright protection116PENANA7uRfTiozZi

Toby then walked in the room and dragged her out by her scarf.copyright protection116PENANAUMc3deef2t

“Well that happened,” EJ said as he turned to face me. He had a serious aura around him. “Tori… I have something to tell you.. And ask you.” His tone was definitely super cereal.copyright protection116PENANAtQCWnVDbOx

“Why so serious, EJ?” I said, quoting the Joker from Batman.copyright protection116PENANAlV2cbVvzvu

“Because I wanted to tell you that I’m sorry for killing Jaye. I mean, I was supposed to anyways, and especially after what he did to you.” EJ lifted up his mask a little bit, revealing some bloosh. “It made me realize that I.. Well.. That I wanna know if you’re a volcano, because I lava you.”copyright protection116PENANARph4suiHKk

I blushed before coughing awkwardly, “Uh… EJ, I’m sorry to break this to you, but…” I began to scoot away, but it was pointless, seeing that EJ scooted closer to me with every move I made.copyright protection116PENANAaebMbyIPKw

Suddenly, Ash came running into the room with a Jerry can (gasoline can) and a box of matches. Ash snapped his fingers, getting EJ’s attention. EJ quickly pulled his mask back down. “Hey, EJ!” He then began to grin, “Come with me please!”copyright protection116PENANAm5spiDlNcQ

EJ clicked his tongue, signaling that he was rolling his eyes, if he had any because he is eyeless.copyright protection116PENANAi4fz8I4qpO

“What do you need?” EJ asked Ash as he walked over to him.copyright protection116PENANALA2Wndv52f

“Oh nothing.. Just wanna make some fried chicken.” Even I blinked at Ash.copyright protection116PENANACpl5PDIarV

“Fried chicken?” EJ scoffed, “I hate fried chicken. I only eat kidneys and sometimes eat meat that humans eat, remember?”copyright protection116PENANA1JZgj7Znyp

“Oh ho ho,” Ash said, handing me his box of matches. “But you’ll love these. C’mon let’s make ‘em outside so Slenderp doesn’t get his panties in a twist.”copyright protection116PENANAcjZefmsLsv

I chuckled as I followed Ash and EJ outside. Then it hit me. Why was Ash using a gasoline can and matches to make fried chicken? I just shook it off. Maybe it’s a method Ash made up that works really well? Who knows.copyright protection116PENANA05VmaK0TVs

We soon arrived at the place Ash wanted us to go (which was out back, not quite by the gardens). He had me stand near the garden, as away from EJ as possible.copyright protection116PENANAOWbNdvUcSt

“Where’s the stupid grill?” EJ asked.copyright protection116PENANAB4MBj2YMNq

“Don’t need one,” Ash grinned like the devil himself, “Not for what we’re making~!” Ash opened the gasoline can and set it down before grabbing my hand and pulling me close. “Careful who you flirt with, EJ.” Ash warned.copyright protection116PENANAiOwdaHXbAT

“Why do you care?” EJ spat, “It’s not like--” EJ stopped speaking when Ash kissed me on the cheek. EJ suddenly was seething with rage. “Why you--”copyright protection116PENANADoPOc2k7fc

Ash let me go, grabbed the gasoline can, and threw the gasoline all over EJ. Ash took the box of matches from my hands and lit one, shouted “Welcome to EFC, home of the EYELESS FRIED CHICKEN!!” and threw a match on him (Kubz Scoutz reference, courtesy of Sarah the Stalker :3). EJ caught on fire.copyright protection116PENANAARhmsBpqnc

He screamed in pain as he tried to put the fire out. Ash just laughed like a maniac, “That’s what you get for trying to mess with my girl!” Ash then picked me up bridal style and made a mad dash for the house.copyright protection116PENANARF0oTb5RmF

Ash set me down on my feet once we were in the main hallway. Sarah came walking in with a grin on her face. “Did you just open up an EFC, Ash?”copyright protection116PENANAKZ4zOgC9nR

“Yes,” He chuckled.copyright protection116PENANAlYIDkafJBC

“Noice,” She said and gave him a high-five. “Anyways, I’m playing a game with Toby. If he asks, you didn’t see me, okay?”copyright protection116PENANAWtiXRc9W3v

“Okay,” I said with a shrug. Sarah must’ve heard Toby’s ticks, because she took the air vent cover off. “Peace!” She quickly climbed into the air vent and put the cover back on.copyright protection116PENANACNvHnkXZtl

Toby soon came down the stairs, “I heard *twitch* her voice! She was here, yeah?” Ash nodded and I nudged him in the ribs.copyright protection116PENANAQPjytEJIol

“She went that way!” Ash said, pointing in the opposite direction, which happened to be out the front door.copyright protection116PENANAlkODiFQrCT

“Ash! How dare you give her location away!” I hissed at him.copyright protection116PENANAXfHsX4NV4g

Toby just smiled, “Thanks guys!” He then ran out the door, “I’M COMING FOR *crack* YOU, SARAH!!”copyright protection116PENANAgU6AtzfdhD

Ash and I look at each other for a moment before bursting out with laughter. “I can’t believe he fell for it!” I say.copyright protection116PENANAyCYmgh26IF

“I know right! That was hilarious! Along with the thing with EJ,” Ash laughs.copyright protection116PENANA0FVH8SMWNQ

I sigh, “Yeah...haven’t I seen that in a video before?”copyright protection116PENANAd4LjFfTUsa

Ash looks at me questioningly. “Seen what?”copyright protection116PENANAy1Nwo3Nqaw

“The whole ‘cover someone with gasoline and flick a match on them because they flirted with your bae’ kinda thing,” I say. “Oh yeah, I think Sarah showed me a video by a youtuber she watches… Kubz Scoutz I think…”copyright protection116PENANA6ac2RlUEhI

Ash just laughs and shakes his head. “The kind of stuff Sarah gets you into…”copyright protection116PENANAvuNgOswHmZ

“Yeah,” I said, laughing, “She means well, though.”copyright protection116PENANARU0EroIfPS

“I know. I've known her since second grade!” Ash laughed.copyright protection116PENANALW2XYUjTyA

We were silent for a moment before Ash spoke up again, “Wanna go out back? There’s a garden with a gazebo.” copyright protection116PENANAB35okTRQAd

“You know what? That would be nice,” I said. Ash smiled and took my hand in his.copyright protection116PENANAQs8Q7zfPO5

“Then let’s go, Tori.” Ash said as he walked with me out the back door to the garden.copyright protection116PENANAHA1Ky0ERTd

The garden was beautiful with a Victorian Era flair. Also, like Ash promised, there was a gazebo in the center of it all. I smiled to myself. I turned around and saw Ash had picked a white rose and was offering it to me.copyright protection116PENANArvhwUBqLs1

“For the prettiest Torturer I know,” Ash said softly, the corners of his mouth lifting into a smile. I blushed as I took the flower.copyright protection116PENANAZit79BHpqw

“This is so sweet…” I whispered, smelling the lovely scent.copyright protection116PENANAu86vTFwxwp

“Heheh… Sarah said those were your favorite… So I kinda figured…” Ash trailed off. Suddenly, Sarah came barreling from the gazebo with Toby on her tail.copyright protection116PENANALYV2vQDVB6

Sarah quickly got away into the mansion. Toby shook his head at Ash.copyright protection116PENANAWBpqJy1qXs

“She was pulling a Balloon Boy and was in the air vents. She also pulled a freaking Haruhi and Tamaki and hid under the gazebo, which was ironically the episode we were watching earlier,” Toby laughed almost crazily, “I’ve got a Stalker to catch~!”copyright protection116PENANAWsA3YtIu1f

Soon after Toby left, Ash and I burst into laughter.copyright protection116PENANAUMdPOIFsEh

“That was amazing!” I finally said after I stopped laughing.copyright protection116PENANAyATY1Cw22u

“It was..” Ash said, pretending to wipe a tear from his eye. “Anyways,” Ash linked his elbow with mine, “I think we should just relax for a little while… Before Slenderp finds out I made some EFC.”copyright protection116PENANAuZX53VzMpB

I laughed, “That’s probably a really good idea. Besides,” I said as we walked over to the gazebo and sat down, “We can talk about stuff.”copyright protection116PENANA1koe9dXPFB

“True,” Ash said. We just sat there and talked and talked until Masky came and got us for dinner.copyright protection116PENANA7eb0cdCJfF

Comments ( 0 )

No comments yet. Be the first!