中藥與西藥的比拼經常出現,箇中經常出現的論據就是中藥缺乏科學精密驗證,純粹是依靠經驗及神農嘗百草的方式積聚理論。319Please respect copyright.PENANAGDZulWDLQq
319Please respect copyright.PENANAhj5cbVKl2c
319Please respect copyright.PENANAfvFW6QfWZd
本篇文章無意將中藥及西藥對衡,而是嘗試以西醫科學角度審視一款中醫藥材,三七。319Please respect copyright.PENANAyZ4nxQ9hgA
319Please respect copyright.PENANAn7TXDZWVqT
319Please respect copyright.PENANAjjsFHIcfHd
319Please respect copyright.PENANABfbpj8wUyA
(圖2)左圖為Panax notoginseng(三七);319Please respect copyright.PENANAEOz0kTY2RD
319Please respect copyright.PENANAO8t6MhmqhC
中圖為Sedum aizoon(土三七);319Please respect copyright.PENANAWtvy0BMfDy
319Please respect copyright.PENANAfCwVU9zOoM
而右圖則為Gynura japonica,頻繁被誤當成土三七的藥材。319Please respect copyright.PENANAD5pIZyT00E
319Please respect copyright.PENANAA6hI6HnBB7
319Please respect copyright.PENANAaJ9rngX3T3
(圖3)不幸的是,這款誤當成土三七的藥材內含名為pyrrolizidine alkaloids (PAs)的化學物;319Please respect copyright.PENANAuMqtbrKlkF
真正的三七及土三七並不含PAs。319Please respect copyright.PENANAxFzd57fMfA
319Please respect copyright.PENANAJL7AGsU7I1
319Please respect copyright.PENANAXeYg7OLmPh
319Please respect copyright.PENANASuH2N4JiuK
這些PA化學物進入人體後,會形成DHPA及DHP化學物。319Please respect copyright.PENANApptxVakjEm
319Please respect copyright.PENANAtSVA8zNNYX
而DHPA及DHP化學物會與肝臟內各種蛋白質結合,導致肝臟無法運作正常。319Please respect copyright.PENANAUgWCO3S6IZ
319Please respect copyright.PENANAOPJ8FTBgI8
根據資料統計(Ref1),誤當Gynura japonica作為土三七下藥,構成了中國在2017年約10-30%因攝取藥物導致肝臟收損的個案。319Please respect copyright.PENANArf6WFNXL4y
319Please respect copyright.PENANAQ0IkcdZLwv
這亦表示,若有經驗不足的中藥醫師或商人胡亂購買藥材的話,將會無意之間害了別人。319Please respect copyright.PENANAtZjHknGW39
319Please respect copyright.PENANAYjU8s2JZ2X
能否有系統分配及管理中藥藥材的類別,將會是現今中醫所需面對的問題。319Please respect copyright.PENANAXNfSsQ3D7Z
319Please respect copyright.PENANAPye70ejSLC
有興趣繼續觀看用西醫角度觀看中藥的話,請給予正評及留言,反應熱烈的話將會寫新一集。319Please respect copyright.PENANAFYa70FPSHR
319Please respect copyright.PENANAojsIFHCIJL
如果想我快啲出文的話,請入去Penana網站科普專欄–薯不揀單俾一個like以及Bookmark,這對我非常之重要。319Please respect copyright.PENANA3EJbg1uBF8
319Please respect copyright.PENANAArYqVjLpV0
Link: https://www.penana.com/story/66244/%E7%A7%91%E6%99%AE%E5%B0%88%E6%AC%84-%E8%96%AF%E4%B8%8D%E6%8F%80%E5%96%AE/toc319Please respect copyright.PENANA6IF2thp053
319Please respect copyright.PENANA58ML3epieS
同時亦可以在Penana網站裡按「買一嚿/半嚿薯仔」,以課金的方式推動我繼續搜羅資料寫文,多謝。319Please respect copyright.PENANAFOkyOv2Q13
319Please respect copyright.PENANAxstxhw76f3
Link:319Please respect copyright.PENANAaeBX769CtL
https://www.penana.com/user/27349/%E8%96%AF%E4%BB%94%E8%81%9E%E8%8C%B1%E8%8E%89/portfolio319Please respect copyright.PENANAASTaHP5wGV
319Please respect copyright.PENANArwFP1bpipe
319Please respect copyright.PENANASB8x3EZXfv
有興趣接收科學資訊的話,歡迎follow IG: potatopigtongue。319Please respect copyright.PENANAsFvTnLPdhx
319Please respect copyright.PENANAvHEQvbOzVS
https://www.instagram.com/potatopigtongue/319Please respect copyright.PENANAwBaiINJInd
319Please respect copyright.PENANAiijY9PCyhb
319Please respect copyright.PENANAwAo6DeBPCA
Ref1:https://www.nature.com/articles/s41401-020-00553-9319Please respect copyright.PENANA7POVnBkSSb